Holden caulfield differs from all the other characters in the novel because he is putatively the narrator actually it is j d salinger who is writing the novel but using the fictitious persona. Huckleberry finn, is less judgmental and more self-examining a holden's storytelling ability along with his desire for adventure makes him similar to huck and serves to remind readers that despite their mature examinations of society, both are still young narrators with immature qualities. An analysis of the similarities between holden caulfield in the catcher in the rye by jd salinger and huckleberry finn in the adventures of huckleberry finn by mark twain. Jelena has 186 quotes liked quotes liked quotes liked quotes, is huckleberry finn holden caulfield essay writing services each oterr one of the click here three weeks to the guiding questions everything holden caulfield phonies essay help. A comparative analysis of the protagonists in catcher in the rye and adventures of huckleberry finn i introduction holden caulfield is the protagonist of catcher in the rye, as huckleberry finn is a.
An archive of our own, a project of the organization for transformative works. Holden caulfield, the main character of the catcher in the rye, is hovering between adolescence and adulthood holden is on the edge of the cliff trying to hold on to his youth for as long as possible. Jerome david salinger (1919-2010) matched mark twain's achievement in huckleberry finn, of presenting the story of a rebellious and kind-hearted teenager, holden caulfield, in the very specific. To compare the character in that book, a kid named holden caulfield, to huck in the adventures of tom sawyer and the adventures of huckleberry finn was preposterous, i thought.
This paper proposes to delineate the characteristics of holden caulfield, the adolescent protagonist hero of jd salinger's the catcher in the rye and illuminate the reasons as to why this prototype of brooding adolescence, displaying a rather uber-cool style of disaffection, disenchantment and disillusionment became an indispensable figure. Although huck finn is skeptical of religion and societal rules, especially about slavery, holden caulfield is the opposite of the trusting character of huck finn holden caulfield sees everyone except children to be goddamn phony bastards and allows the negative aspects of life to raid his thoughts. Salinger was the son of a jewish father and a christian mother, and, like holden caulfield, the hero of the catcher in the rye, he grew up in new york city, attending public schools and a military academy after brief periods at new york and columbia universities, he devoted himself entirely to writing, and his stories began to appear in.
There is no question that harper lee's book to kill a mockingbird is an american classic, but it's also been controversial from the moment it was published most recently it was banned for. Holden caulfield is not so innocent, he's older than huckleberry and experienced enough to see through the phony adult world, even if he's powerless to confront it both voices are distinct. If you've read jd salinger's classic and you're looking for books similar to the catcher in the rye, then this list of 10 books is for you you were blown away by the fast paced dialogue and acerbic and insightful wit of holden caulfield. Summary: when comparing mark twain's huckleberry finn and jd salinger's catcher in the rye, holden caulfield's fist person narrative is proven to be more effective the author's use of realism, tone, and word choice establishes a strong understanding of the narrator based on what holden chooses.
The adventures of huck finn is a novel based on the adventures of a boy named huck finn, who along with a slave, jim, make their way along the mississippi river during the nineteenth century the catcher in the rye is a novel about a young man called holden caulfield, who travels from pencey prep to new york city struggling with his own. Huckleberry finn is a completely different character he is probably the polar opposite of holden caulfield, because he is much surer of himself he is constantly leaning in to adulthood, making decisions that could change people's lives, and he doesn't think anything of it. In the first novel, the adventures of huckleberry finn, author mark twain uses this story to show the immorality of society in the 1800's to convey this message, he uses his main character, a rebellious adolescent named huck finn. The characters huck finn and holden caulfield portion a particular bond both male childs are the most improbable of heroes they lie deceive act irresponsibly yet they get the point across besides there is a connexion between the comrades of each character. The catcher in the rye was written in 1951, just several years after the end of wwii in the 1950s, among other things, there was an adherence to the idea of domesticity, of having a respectable upbringing, living a good life, etc in an era in which lines were paved out for people, holden caulfield.
The catcher in the rye is a 1951 novel by j d salinger  a controversial novel originally published for adults, it has since become popular with adolescent readers for its themes of teenage angst and alienation. The characters' metamorphoses in adventures of huckleberry finn, color purple, and catcher in the the main characters of the adventures of huckleberry finn, the color purple, and the catcher in the rye begin their stories as lonely, confined, and dependent people battling with their own thoughts versus societal pressures. Colloquialism in the adventures of huckleberry finn by mark twain in the adventures of huckleberry finn , mark twain's narrator and title character, huck finn narrates his story using colloquial language that includes idioms and words specific to a regional dialect. To begin with, there was that voice like no other voice you ever heard authentic, real, genuine, immediate mark twain, when he wrote huckleberry finn, might have sounded like that to contemporary readers and of course that novel is wonderful, but there is something about the salinger voice that is special.
In the novels adventures of huckleberry finn and catcher in the rye, both of the protagonists, despite the different settings, the other characters, their restrictions and the different people that they are, are searching for the same thing - themselves. There are some thematic connections between holden caulfield and jay gatsby: deception, self-deception and illusion/delusion jay gatsby is a person who intentionally obscures his past and lies. Cleveland state university [email protected] etd archive 2014 structural and symbolic parallels within the adventures of huckleberry finn and the catcher in.