The battle of the endings george bernard shaw wrote the play pygmalion in 1913, which was made into a musical in 1956 by alan jay lerner, called my fair lady, filmed in 1964 by george cukor, both are quite entertaining but are not exactly like. My fair lady and pygmalion: connections and contrasts through the years, countless film directors have adapted and recreated various novels and plays to make them ideal for the big-screen. My fair lady is a 1964 musical film adaptation of the original stage play pygmalion although it has won numerous awards and accolades by critics, it is often that literature lovers and shaw's fans compare the film and the original play and the manner in which shaw's concepts and ideas are portrayed. Pygmalion is a play by george bernard shaw, named after a greek mythological figureit was first presented on stage to the public in 1913 in ancient greek mythology, pygmalion fell in love with one of his sculptures, which then came to life. The film pygmalion is more conventionally romantic than the stage play of the same name, and my fair lady (both on stage and on film) retained the ending of the film pygmalion.
The comparison of social classes through analysis of pygmalion pygmalion , a play by george bernard shaw, portrays the transformation of a cockney flower girl, eliza doolittle, into a professional woman through the handiwork of her sculptor, professor henry higgins. The comparative study of pygmalion by bernard shaw and pretty woman by gary marshall has enhanced my perception of the shared concerns of the two texts. Pygmalion & my fair lady the play pygmalion and my fair lady, the musical, are the same story the only major difference between the two, is that my fair lady has songs added to the dialogue i believe the musical version is more enjoyable because the music adds more feeling to the story.
My fair lady is, as my summary states, the most intelligent musical ever made adapted by lerner and lowe from non-musical pygmalion by george bernard shaw, it is filled with clever, witty dialogue lavish sets, a superb cast, and wonderful songs make this film a masterpiece. A comparison of pygmalion and my fair lady 647 words 1 page a comparison of the play pygmalion and movie anastasia 636 words 1 page an analysis of pygmalion. My fair lady, of course, was written in the 1950s by the all-star musical theatre duo of lerner and loewe it is based on george bernard shaw's 1913 play pygmalion , itself inspired by the ancient greek myth about a sculptor who falls in love with his own marble creation. Fernando lutfalla comparing pygmalion with my fair lady pygmalion is a novel written by bernard shaw which portrays a comedy story in 1964 however, george cukor, director of my fair lady, created the film hoping to retain some similarities and also incorporate a few changes of his own.
One difference is that in the play pygmalion, eliza enters the room when her father is finishing his busines of letting her go for a sum of five pounds she is dressed in a japanese kimono and. The tone of pygmalion is darker and more realistic than that of my fair lady, which is a work of fantasy composed in a light and comedic style the opening of my fair lady prior to meeting mr higgins is very true to pygmalion.
My fair ladythe academy award-winning musical film my fair lady produced by george cukor in 1964, was based on the play pygmalion by george bernard shaw written in 1913 although, the basic story line and underlying themes are the same, there are a number of differences between the two famous works. Since 1956, and its triumphant opening on broadway, the greatest obstacle to the fulfilment of shaw's wishes, has been my fair lady, lerner and loewe's musical adaptation of pygmalion. There's a lot said here comparing pygmalion to my fair lady that's really a classic apples-and-oranges fallacy musical theatre is an entirely different art form, with a different goal. - pygmalion & my fair lady the play pygmalion and my fair lady, the musical, are the same story the only major difference between the two, is that my fair lady has songs added to the dialogue i believe the musical version is more enjoyable because the music adds more feeling to the story.
My fair lady included these characters which aren't inlcuded in pygmalion: mrs pearce who is the head of henry higgins household, mrs eynsford-hill who is freddy's mother, and zoltan karpathy who is henry higgins former student and higgin's rival. The wildly successful musical my fair lady, produced for the stage in 1956 and as a film in 1964, is based on the play pygmalion, penned in 1913 by irish author george bernard shaw.
Comparing and contrasting pygmalion and my fair lady user description: as part of the adaptations and transformations sac in year 12 vce literature, students must complete an analysis of a text and compare/contrast it to it a recreation of that text. We offer the ability to read the following pygmalion essay if you want to find our what similarities pygmalion by ovid and pygmalion by shaw have why are two such plays different by time of writing, and by the nature of the authors' literary masterpieces combined in our perception. My fair lady is a much better laid-out and a better all-around movie than pygmalion right off, the first difference i noted was that my fair lady was in color, as opposed to pygmalion.